Methodology
Where the data comes from
PET TOXIC? reads from a pinned snapshot of two ASPCA sources, dated 2026-11-17:
- The ASPCA toxic and non-toxic plant list. The snapshot holds 1,023 plant entries: houseplants, garden plants, trees and weeds, each with its status for dogs, cats and horses as the ASPCA records them.
- The ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center (APCC) top-toxins picture, as 31 common non-plant items (xylitol, chocolate, antifreeze, ibuprofen and other NSAIDs, alcohol, essential oils and more) grouped into 55 toxin categories. Each category carries symptoms to watch and a call-the-ER-now threshold, written in English and Spanish from APCC guidance.
Every entry in the tool links to its aspca.org source page on the verdict card. ASPCA is cited as the data source only. PET TOXIC? has no affiliation with, and no endorsement by, the ASPCA.
How the data is refreshed
The data is a snapshot, not a live feed. We re-pin it periodically from the same ASPCA sources, and every refresh carries a new date. That date is always shown on the page as “Data pinned <date>.” Trust what the page shows you today, and treat an old-looking date as a reason to call.
Severity bands are editorial
Verdicts land in one of four bands: TOXIC, mildly toxic, not expected to be toxic, and not on the ASPCA list. Toxic verdicts carry a triage band: high (call now), moderate, or low (usually self-limiting). These bands are our own editorial triage in the style of APCC guidance. They are labeled that way in the tool itself. They are never presented as the official severity.
Not veterinary advice
A verdict card is information that helps you decide whether to call. It is not a diagnosis and never replaces your vet. When in doubt, call your vet or the ASPCA Animal Poison Control hotline: 888-426-4435.
Honest limits
- It is a snapshot. The ASPCA list can change after our pin date.
- Coverage is strongest for plants. With 1,054 items in total, a specific product brand, a human medicine dose form or a rare species may simply not be listed. That returns “not on the ASPCA list,” which means unknown, not safe.
- Species are dogs, cats and horses only. Rabbits, birds and other pets are out of scope for now.
- Horse coverage is thinner: about one in four entries (259 of 1,054) has no horse status in the ASPCA record.
- Statuses differ per species. A true lily (Lilium) is toxic for cats and shows as not listed for dogs. Always pick your species before you trust a line.
- No dose math. We do not calculate how much is dangerous for your pet's weight. Amount matters, so tell the hotline exactly how much was eaten.
- Spanish: the interface and all triage text are bilingual. 144 of the most common items also carry Spanish names; the rest show their English name inside the Spanish interface.